NECESSARY WISDOM
The next five
clusters of big questions all relate to issues of how we, as humans, can best live
our lives. Answers to these questions ideally flow directly from our answers to
the first four groups of questions concerning identity and purpose. If we have
a handle on identity, know what we really want in life, and understand our life
purpose, we probably have a general idea of how we want to live. However,
problems commonly arise when we attempt to deal with the specifics, and put our
general ideas into practice on a day-by-day basis with real people. Frequently,
we have to make choices between two or more possible responses to a situation,
and not one of the options is a clear expression of our purpose statement. On
many occasions, we simply do not know the best way to respond, and we require
further information or wisdom before we can make such a response. This is when
we may turn to our trusted authorities or “wise ones” in life.
We may define
“trusted authorities” as individuals or groups that have at some time conveyed
to us what we consider as reliable and trustworthy information or advice. They
might include our parents, or parental figures, teachers, clergy, counsellors,
writers, scientists, researchers, speakers, religious prophets or teachers with
messages from “God”, or groups of experts on a particular topic. Most of us
consult such authorities on a regular basis, but we may not always be
consciously aware of doing this. We might simply remember the advice and forget
that a particular person passed it onto us at a certain time in our past. If we
are fortunate, we may have some of our authorities still physically available
to us and we can ask them for advice on the spot. Usually, we have to consult
many of our authorities through memories of what they said or wrote, or by
searching books, media or the internet.
This particular set
of big questions challenges us to reflect on our trusted authorities and
clarify them so we can better judge the ongoing validity or usefulness of their
advice, and be more aware of when we are making decisions based on their information.
These queries are logically the first of the “how to live” questions to
consider, because answers to other questions will commonly be based on who we
consider our authorities to be - especially
if our key authority is a “God” or religious prophet. This exploration of our
authorities relates to the “Necessary Wisdom” stage in the Wayfarer myth where
the main character seeks wise advice from trusted authorities before setting
out on their quest.
So who or what are
the possible authorities available to us, and what are some of the potential problems
with these authorities.
Our most obvious source
of authority will be our personal experience and we all learn many valuable and
often painful lessons from this “wise one”.
The values ingrained
during childhood by our significant parental figures will also provide an authoritative
voice urging us to behave one way and not another. Unfortunately, some of the
advice we remember from childhood is no longer appropriate once we become
adults and must make decisions for ourselves.
For those who have
adopted a set of religious beliefs, the teachings of that religion will be a
significant authority and motivating factor in how we behave. In most cases, a
religious response will include the assumption that the ultimate authority is “God”,
“the gods”, or a trusted “messenger of the gods”, although every believer has
to grapple with the issue of how they can be sure that particular wise advice actually
comes from God. To solve this problem, in some faiths, the authority is said to
reside in sacred writings or scriptures, but the believer then has to deal with
the issue of how best to translate and interpret these texts. Some sacred texts
were not actually written by the religious prophet or “god” who is quoted in
the text, and adherents have to determine the extent to which the writer might
also have included his or her own agenda in writing the text.
Many people claim to
place their trust in science and scientific research, but this can be a problem
when research is inconclusive or there are different interpretations of results.
Some people place
their trust in other established organizations that offer advice on how to live
e.g. a trusted consumer organization might influence the buying patterns of
some people, or others might trust the advice coming from a particular environmental
group. Again, we have to be sure that the advice does not push a particular
political or other agenda hidden behind the advice offered by these
organizations.
Many people still
assume that media organizations and their reports can be trusted. We sometimes
hear people say things like, “If it is in the newspaper, or on the telly, it
must be true!” Unfortunately, media organizations have been known to “stretch”
the truth on occasions to increase their sales or exposure, and many of them
will push political or corporate agendas if it is in their interests.
Increasingly, people
are turning to an internet search engine to collect advice on almost any topic
one can imagine. However, as we enter each site, we face the problem of
determining how reliable, authoritative and unbiased the included advice might
be.
The same problem
applies to each “word of wisdom” from individual “wise ones” such as mentors,
writers, teachers, clergy, counsellors, public speakers, politicians, broadcasters
and other wise ones from whom we might seek advice on a particular
issue.
It seems that almost
every organization or individual has his or her own particular agenda and some stake
in having us accept them as one of our authorities. So much advice, so many
authorities, but who can we trust?
Some would argue
that we should not trust any particular authority and instead, complete our own
independent research on each topic we encounter. Whilst we might need to do our
own research on some issues, no one has the time to research or have a
first-hand experience of everything, so we need some way we can build trust in
authorities who do some of the research for us, or who have actually “been
there”.
We can build our
level of trust in authorities in a similar way to the way we build trust in a
friend. It takes time, familiarity, encounters over a wide range of contexts
and a growing faith based on evidence that our friend or authority is not out
to exploit us. There seems to be seven key questions we can ask of potential
authorities in relation to wisdom or advice on a particular issue. My
suggestion is that we determine positive answers to all or most of these questions
before we accept a potential authority as a trusted authority.
The Seven Questions to Ask of a Potential Authority on a Particular Issue
-
Expert Experience:
Does the authority have the recent experience or qualifications to qualify them
as a current expert in the field of this particular issue, or do they refer to
experts who have such reasonable, recent qualifications and experience? - We tend to trust people who have the
relevant qualifications and current experience with a particular issue.
-
Peer Reviewed: Are
the views or claims of this authority respected by a wide range of their peers
in the field of this issue? - We are
likely to trust people who are trusted by their peers.
-
Understanding: Is
the authority coming from an experience of life that we understand, or do they
show that they seem to understand where we are coming from? We tend to trust people who understand our situation in life.
-
Consistent: Are
the views of this authority on other issues with which we are familiar similar
to, or consistent with views held by other trusted authority figures we consult? We tend to trust people who have views
consistent with our other experts or wise ones.
-
Familiarity: Have
we encountered references to this authority over a period of time and in a
range of situations e.g. in different types of media, in a range of books by
different authors? We tend to trust
people with whom we have familiarity over time and in a range of situations.
-
No Agendas: Does
this authority seem to be free from any hidden agendas or stakes in providing
their advice on this particular issue? We
are more likely to trust people who do not seem to be selling something or
trying to manipulate us.
-
Proven: Has
advice from this authority “worked” for us in the past? We tend to trust people who have a proven record of accomplishment
in giving us reliable advice.
Asking these
questions about potential authorities can be quite a time intensive process, so
like good friends, once we find a trusted authority on an issue, we need to
treasure them as one of the most important resources we have on our life journey.
They can save us from falling into many traps along the pathways of life.
One way of treasuring
our authorities is to create a “Wise Ones Collection” or list of our trusted
authorities in the various dimensions of life. We can learn much about
ourselves by simply compiling such a starting list of our major authorities.
However, if we continue the practice, and our list grows, it could well become
a vital reference when we need somewhere to go for trustworthy advice in the
future.
Our “Wise Ones
Collection” will serve as our working answer to Big Question 5.
